Results

Mackle-more of What Matters

If Napoleon Dynamite made moon boots cool for a few, Macklemore’s new single “Thrift Shop” has made thrift store treasures, well, cool for everyone.

I’m sure you’ve heard the song by now—it’s been at the top of the charts for over seven weeks. (If you haven’t heard it yet, check it out on YouTube. Warning: some adult language.) The song is incredibly catchy, and it’s sure to get stuck in your head. But what stands out more than the funky beat and pulsing horn hook is the message.  

It’s about shopping at a thrift store. It’s about wearing your mammy’s hand-me-downs instead of a $50 Gucci t-shirt. It’s about saving money. And the people love it.

What’s going on here?

Macklemore is an independent rapper from Seattle. He and producer Ryan Lewis have been a duo since 2000. For more than a decade, they have quietly built a following, playing local shows around the Pacific Northwest. They saved up their money and independently produced their first studio album, “The Heist,” last October.

The hit single “Thrift Shop” has since gone quadruple platinum, and clocks in at roughly 146 million views on YouTube to date. That’s half the population of the United States. Again, this is a rap about wearing used pajamas. 

Not only is the message unique, but Macklemore and Lewis pretty much did it on their own. They have achieved this success with only marginal distribution help from a major label. It’s just the second time in history that an independent artist has topped the Billboard Top 100, and the first time in 20 years.

How did this happen?

Well, certainly social media and the digitization of music helped. People have greater access and sharing capabilities than ever before. But at a deeper level, culturally, how did this happen? Hip-hop is supposed to be about gold teeth and Cadillacs, and popular music should be fun and superficial, right?

Macklemore’s music is lighthearted, yet thoughtful. He raps with a sincerity that’s hard to find in an industry obsessed with money, sex, and pride. He raps about real issues. From his playful dealings with buying used clothes, to more somber musings about substance abuse and gay marriage, his songs seem to come from his heart and mind. This is not typical. He explains his motivation for “Thrift Shop” here:

“You know, I love thrift shopping. It is something that has been a part of my life since I was a young kid, and it’s outside of the box. I like to write songs about my life and things that make me a unique person, and thrift shopping is one of those. Hip-hop is usually an art form that is about...bling, consumption. But [Thrift Shop], it’s about, you know, just saving money. And I think that that’s something that's rare in hip-hop culture. It’s usually about spending money.”

Macklemore and Lewis are questioning consumerism and crossing norms. Based on the song’s success, the message seems to resonate. Perhaps thrifting is not only for hipsters, the poor, and Napoleon Dynamite. Perhaps rappers can be socially conscious. And perhaps our culture is ready to embrace a second look at consumerism.

But this is not Macklemore’s purpose, it’s mostly just who he is. He doesn’t identity as a “conscious rapper,” nor does he even admit to trying to get people to change their behavior. He confesses that the song stems from reflecting on himself—and his own consumerism. Change starts with the individual, says Macklemore:

“It’s my fight, personally, first and foremost, so I don’t go into it thinking, like, I want to change people’s minds or I want to change hip-hop. I go into it thinking, why do I feel the need to consume? Why do I have a closet full of Jordans that I don’t really even wear? So it starts with a personal search and then it translates into an audience.

But, first and foremost, it’s just me going through my closet. That’s how this song was written, was just taking accountability for who I am as a person and how I fall into consumerism in America.”

People can identify with this. It’s refreshing to not be preached at. Not to be told what to buy, think, and do. I think that’s why the song has become such a success. It doesn’t force anything on you, but it allows you to live up your thriftiness at your own leisure.

People want thriftiness to be cool, and thanks to Macklemore, it’s off-the-charts awesome.

Ryan Dwyer graduated from the University of Nevada, Reno, with a bachelor’s degree in Psychology and a minor in Philosophy. He is currently an intern with the Center for a New American Dream.

« More Posts

Comments

I downloaded the “super clean radio version” from Amazon so I could enjoy the beat & message with my kids.

Posted by njtibb at March 17, 2013 at 11:36am

I’m with Leah S. It’s a fun song but it’s too bad there’s not a cleaner, non-sexist version out there. It won’t get any more play with us.

Posted by HMA at March 14, 2013 at 11:55am

I remember the thrill of thrift shopping through college and I continue to shop at my thrift store down the road. Now my teens hear this song and jam out with me. Love it, and the exaggerated male sexual ego tone is comical, I like to think that Mackelmore is also taking a dig at the over the top sexism in hip hop. Great article Ryan!

Posted by Melivist at March 13, 2013 at 11:43am

Not only does the song celebrate thrift shopping, but it also calls out the silliness of spending $50 on a tshirt. Really perspective shifting for the masses. I love that New Dream blogged about this song!

Posted by Lisa at March 12, 2013 at 4:15pm

I love the message it’s just too bad he couldn’t have been thriftier with his bad language. It hits me especially hard when there is a child’s voice in the music and in the video. Call me old fashioned!
I have always been a big time thrift shopper and am glad to hear about the artist’s success w/o a major label backing him. I appreciated reading more about the genesis of the music. Great article.

Posted by Leah S. at March 12, 2013 at 12:49pm

Right on target. May thriftiness rock on!

Posted by H Wise at March 12, 2013 at 12:34pm

Search

Connect with Us